Protein Before or After Workout? Here’s the EVIDENCE

Summary

The article "The Effect of Protein Timing on Muscle Strength and Hypertrophy: A Meta-Analysis" explores the impact of protein consumption around exercise on muscle strength and growth. The study uses a multi-level meta-regression analysis of randomized controlled trials to determine if protein timing enhances post-exercise muscular adaptations. Despite its popularity as a dietary strategy, the effectiveness of protein timing in chronic training studies has shown mixed results, necessitating this comprehensive investigation.

Findings

Muscle Growth Impact 🌱: A small to moderate effect on muscle hypertrophy was found due to protein timing (ES = 0.24 ± 0.10), but this effect disappeared when other factors were considered.

Muscle Strength Effect 💪: No significant effect related to protein timing was found on muscle strength.

Total Protein Intake vs. Timing 🍗⏰: The study concluded that total protein intake, rather than timing, explained perceived benefits.

Anabolic Window 🕰️🥤: The analysis couldn't determine a clear anabolic window for protein consumption, postulating it could be as long as 4–6 hours around a training session.

Training Experience 🏋️‍♂️: The majority of studies evaluated subjects inexperienced with resistance exercise, and only four studies with trained subjects met inclusion criteria.

Methodology

The researchers conducted a meta-regression analysis, combining data from multiple randomized controlled trials. The strength analysis comprised 478 subjects and 96 effect sizes (ESs) nested within 41 treatment or control groups across 20 studies. The hypertrophy analysis comprised 525 subjects and 132 ESs within 47 treatment or control groups across 23 studies. By aggregating this data, the study aimed to better understand the relationship between protein timing and muscular adaptations in response to exercise.

Key Terms

Protein Timing 🕒🥤: A dietary strategy that involves consuming protein in and around a training session to facilitate muscular repair, remodelling, and enhancing post-exercise strength and hypertrophy (muscle growth). It's a popular concept but has shown mixed effectiveness in chronic training studies.

Meta-Regression Analysis 📊🔍: A statistical method used in this study to combine data from multiple randomized controlled trials. The analysis aimed to determine whether protein timing affects post-exercise muscular adaptations, including 478 subjects for strength analysis and 525 for hypertrophy analysis.

Muscular Hypertrophy 🏋️‍♂️🌱: Refers to the increase in muscle mass or size. This study examined the effect of protein timing on muscle hypertrophy, showing a small to moderate effect that disappeared when other factors were considered.

Effect Size (ES) 📈: A quantitative measure of the strength or magnitude of a phenomenon. In this study, ES was used to measure the impact of protein timing on muscle growth and strength, with specific values provided for different analyses.

Resistance Exercise 🏋️‍♀️: A type of exercise that causes muscles to contract against an external resistance, aiming to increase strength, tone, mass, and endurance. The study focuses on the adaptative response to resistance exercise and how protein intake relates to these adaptations.

Let's Break it Down: Simplifying the Science

The article conducts a deep dive into the world of protein timing and its effects on muscle strength and growth through long-term resistance training. 🏋️‍♂️💪

A close examination reveals:

Muscle Growth: A small to moderate effect was found on muscle growth (hypertrophy) when considering protein timing (ES = 0.24 ± 0.10). 📊🌱

Muscle Strength: Surprisingly, no significant impact was detected on muscle strength. 🏋️‍♀️❌

Protein Timing vs. Total Intake: An expanded analysis found that the effects of protein timing vanished when other factors were considered. The real key seemed to be the total protein intake rather than the timing of consumption. 🥩⏰

The results shake up the widely held belief that consuming protein before and after workouts is essential for muscle development. 🕒🥛

In practical terms:

Not All About Timing: The timing of protein might not be as pivotal as once thought. 🧐⌛

Total Intake Matters: The overall amount of protein consumed could be vital for muscle enhancement. 🍗📈

This eye-opening study offers athletes, trainers, and fitness lovers vital insights. It emphasizes looking beyond just timing and considering the overall protein consumption to achieve desired muscle gains. 💡🏆

These findings may change the way we think about protein and exercise, focusing more on what we eat rather than when we eat it. 🍽️🎯

Limitations

Unfortunately, the provided excerpt does not contain detailed information about the study's limitations. Typically, meta-analysis studies might face challenges such as variation in study design, participant characteristics, and the quality of the included studies. Differences in protein types, timing, and dosages across the studies could introduce inconsistency in the analysis. The lack of access to full methodologies and outcomes from all the individual studies might also affect the overall conclusions. It is essential to refer to the article's complete text to understand this meta-analysis's specific limitations.

Source: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1186/1550-2783-10-53

🌟 Thank you for joining us 

We want to extend our heartfelt gratitude for taking the time to read our newsletter. As qualified doctors, we want to learn more about optimising our health and the health of our loved ones with accurate and evidence-based information in an era where misinformation can cloud our understanding of health. We’re also the first to share this with the public because we believe that everyone deserves access to credible health insights.

💬 Your feedback is invaluable to us

It fuels our motivation to continually improve and refine our content. Whether it's a suggestion or a correction, we welcome your input with open arms. After all, our goal is to cater to our combined curiosity and answer health-related questions. Just reply to this email 😄 

🌐 Topic Suggestion

We invite you to continue participating actively in our community as we move forward. Share your thoughts, ask questions, and tell us what topics interest you. Is there a specific health condition you'd like us to cover? Are there wellness practices you're interested in exploring? Feel free to reach out to us with your thoughts and ideas. We're here to learn, share, and grow as a community of health enthusiasts. Feel free to hit reply to this email! Together, let's navigate the vast landscape of health with clarity and accuracy.

Thank you once again for being a part of our health-focused family. Stay curious, stay healthy, and stay connected!

Disclaimer

By subscribing to and reading this newsletter, you acknowledge and agree that you voluntarily choose to read the content and use this information at your own risk.

The information provided in this newsletter, including text, graphics, images, and other material, is for informational purposes only and is not intended as a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. The content is not intended to replace the advice of a qualified healthcare professional.

While the information is based on research, it should not be used to disregard or delay seeking advice from a healthcare provider. Always consult a healthcare professional before deciding about your health or medical conditions.

The authors of this newsletter, including qualified doctors, have made every effort to ensure that the information is accurate and current. However, medical knowledge is constantly evolving, and errors can occur. Therefore, this newsletter's authors, editors, and publishers cannot be held responsible for the accuracy, completeness, or suitability of the information for any particular individual or situation.

This newsletter's authors, editors, and publishers are not liable for any direct, indirect, consequential, special, exemplary, or other damages arising from applying the information in this newsletter.